Questions and Arguments

For Your Lawyer to Address

 

       What is IV-D? How did I become a IV-D case?

o         IV-D is a federally regulated government program that is state supervised/county administered, providing welfare services for:

         IV-D Public Assistance cases

         IV-D Non-Public Assistance cases

o         It is a federally funded government program established in 1974 under Title IV of the Social Security Act, which reads:

         Title IV: Grants to States for Aid and Services to Needy Families and Children and for Child Welfare Services

         Part D: Child Support and Enforcement of Paternity

o         IV-D was meant to financially protect mothers who were not expected to work, but rather, expected to stay at home with their child(ren) who were determined �dependent� by the government because they had determined �abandoned� by the father (See Education Booklet #03-02 Definitions)

o         The Congressional intent and purpose of IV-D was to create a system to:

         recover money from the fathers who had children dependent on public assistance for their basic needs, and

         ensure financial support from fathers who's children were at risk of being on public assistance if they didn't receive support

o         Authority for this federal program is found in:

         42 USC 654 (4)(a)(i)(ii) and CFR302.33

o         The government has expanded its reach and erroneously applied the program to every private action, which is unconstitutional.

         A private action is a case where there is no debt to the public authority � where individuals stipulate their own support agreements without government intervention

o         It is not an entitlement program, but it is erroneously implemented like an entitlement program.

o         If payments are sent to the Minnesota Payment Center, your children are on this IV-D welfare program, whether you realize it or not - check your latest court order for the court file #

o         An OFP (Order for Protection) will automatically require a IV-D agency referral, requiring no IV-D application.

o         A public assistance case will automatically require a IV-D agency referral, requiring no IV-D application.

         This includes child-care assistance and medical assistance.

 

 

 

       Who qualifies for IV-D welfare services?

o         Neither parent need to be on public assistance to qualify for this welfare program

o         There are no eligibility standards for this welfare program

         Anyone who applies for the support, collection and enforcement services will get the services, regardless of income , assets, or financial need

o         The IV-D application must be filled out by one of the parents to become effective.

         If no custody has been determined, whatever parent signs up first for IV-D services �wins� temporary custody.

         If custody has been determined, the custodial parent can apply for the services whether they have an existing child support order or not.

o         The parent who signs the IV-D application turns over all legal support rights of the child(ren) over to the county, regarding all legal actions for child support collections and enforcement.

         this is called �the assignment of rights.�

 

       What does the applicant-parent get?

o         The applicant-parent gets FREE services:

         Complete and thorough legal services (by the county attorney) � the applicant-parent never has to hire an attorney or initiate any legal action again

         case worker

         billing and collection services

         computer tracking

         wage-with-holding

         criminal prosecutions

         etc (over 100 FREE services being paid by tax dollars)

o         Once the application is filled out, a county attorney will be at every child support hearing that exists, until the child(ren) have emancipated

o         The county attorney may say they are representing the child; they may say they are representing the case worker; they are really representing the IV-D agency in order to get as much money out of you as possible, because they are funded by federal government reimbursement money and a financial bonus incentive which is based on a percentage of your monthly child support payment collected -- your child support is their revenue stream!

 

 

       Were my constitutional rights violated?

o         Absent notification to you and if you�ve been afforded no opportunity to object to the IV-D services, your constitutional rights to due process were violated � as a parent you have equal say about the rights of your child.

o         The other parent cannot unilaterally assign the rights of your child(ren) over to the county

o         The application gives the county the power to �take charge� of your child and be involved in your child support case until emancipation.

o         Without this application, the county has no jurisdiction in your case, unless the applicant-parent is on public assistance. The state/county has a no compelling state interest in your case if your children are not �dependent� on public assistance for their basic needs. The state/county has no jurisdiction in your private family agreements, absent abuse, neglect, or harm.

o         With this application, the county has no jurisdiction in your case, if you, as the other parent, object to the services.

o         It is unconstitutional if you have been denied the opportunity to complete a privatestipulated agreement.

 

       How do I get my child off these IV-D welfare services?

o         Most county representatives believe their power and authority cannot be removed from your child support case

o         The power and control of the county government agency can be removed in two ways:

         applicant-parent provides written notice to the county case worker to withdraw services (no court action needed)

         See MN Rule 9550.0091 Clients Right to Accept or Reject Services

         the other parent provides a written objection (See Education Booklet #AL03-03: 42 USC 1301(d) Family Protection Objection)

         See Federal Law 42 U.S.C. 1301 (d)

o         The county will lead you to believe that if you are ordered wage-withholding that one parent must sign up for full IV-D services � this is not true.

o         If wage withholding has been court ordered in your case, there is another form called "Non IV-D wage withholding only"

         this service costs $15 a month -- but it is well worth it because it limits the county involvement in your case and it assures the other parent and the judge that the payments will be made


       Were my constitutional rights violated?

o         Absent notification to you and if you�ve been afforded no opportunity to object to the IV-D services, your constitutional rights to due process were violated � as a parent you have equal say about the rights of your child.

o         The other parent cannot unilaterally assign the rights of your child(ren) over to the county

o         The application gives the county the power to �take charge� of your child and be involved in your child support case until emancipation.

o         Without this application, the county has no jurisdiction in your case, unless the applicant-parent is on public assistance. The state/county has no compelling state interest in your case if your children are not �dependent� on public assistance for their basic needs. The state/county has no jurisdiction in your private family agreements, absent abuse, neglect, or harm.

o         With this application, the county has no jurisdiction in your case, if you, as the other parent, object to the services.

o         It is unconstitutional if you have been denied the opportunity to complete a privatestipulated agreement.

 

       How do I get my child off these IV-D welfare services?

o         Most county representatives believe their power and authority cannot be removed from your child support case

o         The power and control of the county government agency can be removed in two ways:

         applicant-parent provides written notice to the county case worker to withdraw services (no court action needed)

         See MN Rule 9550.0091 Clients Right to Accept or Reject Services

         the other parent provides a written objection (See Education Booklet #AL03-03: 42 USC 1301(d) Family Protection Objection)

         See Federal Law 42 U.S.C. 1301 (d)

o         The county will lead you to believe that if you are ordered wage-withholding that one parent must sign up for full IV-D services � this is not true.

o         If wage withholding has been court ordered in your case, there is another form called "Non IV-D wage withholding only"

         this service costs $15 a month -- but it is well worth it because it limits the county involvement in your case and it assures the other parent and the judge that the payments will be made


       Should I get a copy of the IV-D application that was filled out for my case? How do I get a copy?

o         The application has extensive information about you provided by the other parent; it is likely to be inaccurate information regarding your finances, which may create bias against you

         The county does not verify the information for accuracy

o         The application requires the applicant-parent to disclose all the known financial information about you, but the application does not require the applicant to provide any of their own personal financial information.

o         MN statutes state that if you are a subject of any data the agencies are required to provide you that information upon your request.

 

       Is there any benefit to the other parent (non-applicant)?

o         No.

 

       This welfare program must cost a lot � if the applicant gets everything for FREE, who is paying for this?

o         The program is funded from federal tax dollars, state tax dollars, and county property taxes.

o         IV-D for non-public assistance cases is funded by your county property taxes to the tune of $3 million - $5 million additional tax levies per year, depending on your county - yes, you pay property tax so the county can afford to fight you for more child support!

 

 

The IV-D Child Support Enforcement Program is a voluntary program and it is not mandatory if there is no public interest.


 

       Should I get a copy of the IV-D application that was filled out for my case? How do I get a copy?

o         The application has extensive information about you provided by the other parent; it is likely to be inaccurate information regarding your finances, which may create bias against you

         The county does not verify the information for accuracy

o         The application requires the applicant-parent to disclose all the known financial information about you, but the application does not require the applicant to provide any of their own personal financial information.

o         MN statutes state that if you are a subject of any data the agencies are required to provide you that information upon your request.

 

       This welfare program must cost a lot � if the applicant gets everything for FREE, who is paying for this?

o         The program is funded from federal tax dollars, state tax dollars, and county property taxes.

o         IV-D for non-public assistance cases is funded by your county property taxes to the tune of $3 million - $5 million additional tax levies per year, depending on your county - yes, you pay property tax so the county can afford to fight you for more child support!

 

 

The IV-D Child Support Enforcement Program is a voluntary program and it is not mandatory if there is no public interest.


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

�Finally, be strong in the Lord and in the strength of His might. Put on the whole armor of God, that you may be able to stand against the wiles of the devil.� Ephesians 6:10-11

 

CPR Vision Statement: A non-profit research, education, advocacy, and support organization dedicated to conserving family autonomy, encouraging responsibility, and preserving equal protection of parental rights to safeguard their children�s welfare

 

CPR Organization Mission: Bold advocacy, practical education, and compassionate support, through thoughtful, thorough, and accurate analysis that leads people to responsible action that influences less government and protects the rights and responsibilities of both parents, to encourage healthy development and best interests of children, to resolve differences so that fractured families will be strengthened.

 

CPR educational booklets are updated regularly. If you have suggestions on how to improve this brochure, please notify us. To ensure you have the latest version, visit our website.

 

CPR educational booklets do not purport to give legal advice. The information contained herein is general in nature; individual circumstances will always vary. We recommend you consult an attorney for advice and legal representation.

 

CPR is in the process of applying for non-profit status. CPR is currently under umbrella of tax-exempt 501 c(3) organization, Providence House

 

2003 may be copied by permission only � derivative works or reproductions are a violation of copyright without prior authorization from CPR

Explaining IV-D

Challenging The Government Program That

Caused Intervention

Educational Booklet #AL03-02

 

ASK YOUR LAWYER �

 

The purpose of this information is to help ensure that you are asking your lawyer all the pertinent and relevant questions that must be addressed in your motion, affidavit, and memorandum of law, in order to help ensure a thorough argument based on all facets of the law. No argument with merit should be overlooked; and, every document is critical to the record. Your case must be appropriately and adequately presented to the court, to protect and safeguard you for all possible appeal issues.

 

 

Prepared By:

CPR

CPR

P.O. Box 130776

Roseville, MN 55113

 

CPR Voicemail: 651/490-9277

Website: cpr-mn.org

Email: info@cpr-mn.org

 

 

 

 

 

 

Latest Update: August 26, 2003